Application of an Integrated Workmanship Benchmarking Framework to Building Failure in Developing Countries
Downloads
The construction industry is grappling with significant challenges related to measuring and assessing workmanship performance, which has led to instances of poor workmanship and even building failures. Traditional evaluation methods often fall short, underscoring the urgent need for a more integrated approach to performance assessment. Recent research focused on developing integrated performance assessment techniques and indicators for a comprehensive evaluation of building projects. Key factors contributing to poor workmanship include a lack of standardisation, inadequate assessment frameworks, and limited empirical knowledge. In response, this study proposes implementing an integrated benchmarking framework to evaluate workmanship performance more effectively, employing various data collection methods, including case studies, questionnaires, and checklist surveys, to assess workmanship performance across construction sites throughout the project lifecycle. The questionnaire targeted critical success factors, while checklist surveys identified key failure factors at various project stages. The findings reveal that this integrated benchmarking framework significantly reduces building defects and failures, enhancing overall workmanship quality within Trinidad and Tobago’s construction sector. Analysed projects demonstrated a notable decrease in defects and improvements in structural workmanship performance across all phases of the project. These results are expected to facilitate effective workmanship management in construction and promote the development of best practices in developing countries. This integrated benchmarking framework provides a comprehensive tool for evaluating workmanship performance across various building types, considering critical success and failure factors, project structures, and the organisations involved while offering continuous assessments throughout the lifecycle of building projects.
Downloads
[1] Moradi, S., Ansari, R., & Taherkhani, R. (2022). A Systematic Analysis of Construction Performance Management: Key Performance Indicators from 2000 to 2020. Iranian Journal of Science and Technology - Transactions of Civil Engineering, 46(1), 15–31. doi:10.1007/s40996-021-00626-7.
[2] Pheng, L. S., & Ke-Wei, P. (1996). A framework for implementing TQM in construction. TQM Magazine, 8(5), 39–46. doi:10.1108/09544789610146033.
[3] Arain, F. M., Pheng, L. S., & Assaf, S. A. (2006). Contractors’ Views of the Potential Causes of Inconsistencies between Design and Construction in Saudi Arabia. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 20(1), 74–83. doi:10.1061/(asce)0887-3828(2006)20:1(74).
[4] Ali, N. F., & Mansor, M. A. (2022). Specify the Priorities of Indicators for Measuring the Performance Success of Construction Projects. Tikrit Journal of Engineering Sciences, 29(1), 36–45. doi:10.25130/tjes.29.1.4.
[5] Kassa, R., Ogundare, I., Lines, B., Smithwick, J. B., Kepple, N. J., & Sullivan, K. T. (2023). Developing a construct to measure contractor project manager performance competencies. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management. doi:10.1108/ECAM-12-2022-1122.
[6] Chohan, A. H., Awad, J., Ismail, M. A., & Arar, M. S. (2024). Integrating Technology and Heritage Design for Climate Resilient Courtyard House in Arid Region. Civil Engineering Journal, 10(3), 928-952. doi:10.28991/CEJ-2024-010-03-018.
[7] Ibrahim, A., Zayed, T., & Lafhaj, Z. (2024). Enhancing Construction Performance: A Critical Review of Performance Measurement Practices at the Project Level. Buildings, 14(7). doi:10.3390/buildings14071988.
[8] Murguia, D., Chen, Q., Van Vuuren, T. J., Rathnayake, A., Vilde, V., & Middleton, C. (2022). Digital Measurement of Construction Performance: Data-to-dashboard Strategy. IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, 1101(9). doi:10.1088/1755-1315/1101/9/092009.
[9] Ingle, P. V., Gangadhar, M., & Deepak, M. D. (2024). Developing a project performance assessment model for benchmarking the project success of Indian construction projects. Benchmarking, 31(5), 1426–1452. doi:10.1108/BIJ-09-2022-0553.
[10] Fromsa, A., Ararsa, W., & Quezon, E. (2020). Effects of Poor Workmanship on Building Construction and Its Implication to Project Management Practice: A Case Study in Addis Ababa City. Journal of Xidian University, 14(9). doi:10.37896/jxu14.9/128.
[11] Kazaz, A., & Birgonul, M. T. (2005). Determination of Quality Level in Mass Housing Projects in Turkey. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 131(2), 195–202. doi:10.1061/(asce)0733-9364(2005)131:2(195).
[12] Chinwokwu, G. (2000). The Role of Professionals in Averting Collapse. Proceedings of Building Collapse, Causes, Preventing and Remedies, Lagos, Nigeria, 3-4 May, 12-28.
[13] Windapo, B. (2006). The threat of building collapse on sustainable development in the built environment in Nigeria. In Proc., 36th Annual Conf. and General Meeting of the Nigerian Institute of Building on Sustainable Development in the Built Environment, 59-67.
[14] Makinde, F. A. (2007). Minimizing the Collapse of Building in Nigeria. Seminar Paper, Faculty of Environmental Studies, Osun State College of Technology, Esa Oke, Nigeria.
[15] Windapo, A. O., & Rotimi, J. O. (2012). Contemporary issues in building collapse and its implications for sustainable development. Buildings, 2(3), 283–299. doi:10.3390/buildings2030283.
[16] Agwu, M. (2014). Perception Survey of Poor Construction Supervision and Building Failures in Six Major Cities in Nigeria. British Journal of Education, Society & Behavioural Science, 4(4), 456–472. doi:10.9734/bjesbs/2014/6816.
[17] Nima, M. A., Abdul-Kadir, M. R., Jaafar, M. S., & Alghulami, R. G. (2002). Constructability Concepts in West Port Highway in Malaysia. Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, 128(4), 348–356. doi:10.1061/(asce)0733-9364(2002)128:4(348).
[18] Ahzahar, N., Karim, N. A., Hassan, S. H., & Eman, J. (2011). A study of contribution factors to building failures and defects in construction industry. Procedia Engineering, 20, 249–255. doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2011.11.162.
[19] Asante, L. A., & Sasu, A. (2018). The Challenge of Reducing the Incidence of Building Collapse in Ghana: Analyzing the Perspectives of Building Inspectors in Kumasi. SAGE Open, 8(2), 1–12. doi:10.1177/2158244018778109.
[20] Zamil, A. M., Kineber, A. F., & Alhusban, M. (2024). Unveiling the impact of psychological factors on consumer purchase intentions for overall sustainable success in green residential buildings: Using SEM-ANN analysis. Civil Engineering Journal, 10(5), 1455-1474. doi:10.28991/CEJ-2024-010-05-07.
[21] Adetunji, M. (2018). Oyewale Oyeleye, and Oluremi Akinropo Akindele, Assessment of Building Collapse in Lagos Island, Nigeria. American Journal of Sustainable Cities and Society, 7(1), 18 – 28.
[22] Kenechi, S. O. (2021). Failure in building and remedies. ScienceOpen Preprints, 1-19. doi:10.14293/S2199-1006.1.SOR-.PPUBO0E.v1.
[23] Ayininuola, G., & Olalusi, O. (2005). Assessment of Building Failures in Nigeria: Lagos and Ibadan Case Study. African Journal of Science and Technology, 5(1), 73 – 78. doi:10.4314/ajst.v5i1.15321.
[24] Okeke, F. O., Sam-amobi, C. G., & Okeke, F. I. (2020). Role of local town planning authorities in building collapse in Nigeria: evidence from Enugu metropolis. Heliyon, 6(7), 4361. doi:10.1016/j.heliyon.2020.e04361.
[25] ACS (2017). Updating Building Codes of the Greater Caribbean for Winds and Earthquakes (Phase 1), Association of Caribbean States, Trinidad and Tobago. Available online: http://www.acs-aec.org/index.php?q=disaster-risk-reduction/projects/updating-building-codes-of-the-greater-caribbean-for-winds-and-eart. (accessed on May 2025).
[26] CEPAL (2025), Resilient and affordable housing in the Caribbean: Policy recommendations towards a transformative, green and inclusive recovery strategy. United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean, Trinidad and Tobago. Available online: https://repositorio.cepal.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/aada72be-e788-4c06-8c72-71b47ceb8f70/content (accessed on May 2025).
[27] Wilkinson, E., & Steller, R. (2018). The Caribbean Must Think Carefully About How and Where to Build Back Better After the Hurricanes of 2017. LES, London, United Kingdom. Available online: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/latamcaribbean/2018/11/14/the-caribbean-must-think-carefully-about-how-and-where-to-build-back-better-after-the-hurricanes-of-2017/ (accessed on May 2025).
[28] Adenuga, O. A. (2012). Professionals In the Built Environment and The Incidence of Building Collapse in Nigeria. Organization, Technology and Management in Construction: An International Journal, 4(2), 461–473. doi:10.5592/otmcj.2012.2.2.
[29] Awoyera, P. O., Alfa, J., Odetoyan, A., & Akinwumi, I. I. (2021). Building Collapse in Nigeria during recent years – Causes, effects and way forward. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 1036(1), 012021. doi:10.1088/1757-899x/1036/1/012021.
[30] ILO (2023). The Rana Plaza Disaster Ten Years On: What Has Changed? International Labour Organization, Geneva, Switzerland. Available online: https://webapps.ilo.org/infostories/en-GB/Stories/Country-Focus/rana-plaza#intro (accessed on May 2025).
[31] Taiwo, A. A., & Afolami, J. A. (2011). Incessant building collapse: A case of a hotel in Akure, Nigeria. Journal of Building Appraisal, 6(3–4), 241–248. doi:10.1057/jba.2011.1.
[32] Ellingwood, B. R., Smilowitz, R., Dusenberry, D. O., Duthinh, D., Lew, H. S., & Carino, N. J. (2007). Best practices for reducing the potential for progressive collapse in buildings. U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Maryland, United States.
[33] Alinaitwe, H. M. (2009). Prioritising lean construction barriers in Uganda’s construction industry. Journal of Construction in Developing Countries, 14(1), 15–30.
[34] Thiagaragan, T., Zairi, M., & Dale, B. G. (2001). A proposed model of TQM implementation based on an empirical study of Malaysian industry. International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management, 18(3), 289–306. doi:10.1108/02656710110383539.
[35] Toor, S. U. R., & Ogunlana, S. (2009). Ineffective leadership: Investigating the negative attributes of leaders and organizational neutralizers. Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management, 16(3), 254–272. doi:10.1108/09699980910951663.
[36] Metri, B. A. (2005). TQM Critical Success Factors for Construction Firms. Management: Journal of Contemporary Management Issues, 10(2), 61–72.
[37] Yiu, N. S. N., Sze, N. N., & Chan, D. W. M. (2018). Implementation of safety management systems in Hong Kong construction industry – A safety practitioner’s perspective. Journal of Safety Research, 64, 1–9. doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2017.12.011.
[38] Poon, S. W., Tang, S. L., & Wong, F. K. W. (2008). Management and economics of construction safety in Hong Kong. In Management and Economics of Construction Safety in Hong Kong. Hong Kong University Press, Hong Kong.
[39] Choudhry, R. M., Fang, D., & Ahmed, S. M. (2008). Safety management in construction: Best practices in Hong Kong. Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering Education and Practice, 134(1), 20–32. doi:10.1061/(ASCE)1052-3928(2008)134:1(20).
[40] Robson, L. S., Clarke, J. A., Cullen, K., Bielecky, A., Severin, C., Bigelow, P. L., Irvin, E., Culyer, A., & Mahood, Q. (2007). The effectiveness of occupational health and safety management system interventions: A systematic review. Safety Science, 45(3), 329–353. doi:10.1016/j.ssci.2006.07.003.
[41] Hewage, K. N., & Ruwanpura, J. Y. (2006). Carpentry workers issues and efficiencies related to construction productivity in commercial construction projects in Alberta. Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 33(8), 1075–1089. doi:10.1139/L06-050.
[42] Othuman Mydin, M. A., Othman, N. A., & Sani, N. M. (2014). A prospective study on building quality: Relationship between workmanship quality and common building defects of low-cost construction projects. MATEC Web of Conferences, 17(01001), 1–8. doi:10.1051/matecconf/20141701001.
[43] Thamilarasu, V., Rajprasad, J., & Ram Prasanna Pavan, T. (2017). A case study on requirements of quality workmanship in construction projects. International Journal of Civil Engineering and Technology, 8(4), 1061–1067.
[44] Burer, C. (2016). Workmanship In Construction of Small and Medium Hospitality Enterprises in Nairobi Central Business District. Doctoral dissertation, University of Nairobi, Nairobi, Kenya.
[45] Yebichaye, D. (2016). Building Defects Due to Poor Workmanship in Addis Ababa: The Case Study on 20/80 Condominium Houses, Master’s thesis. Addis Ababa University, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
[46] Shebob, A., Dawood, N., & Shah, R. K. (2012). Development of a methodology for analysing and quantifying the impact of delay factors affecting construction projects. Journal of Construction Engineering and Project Management, 2(3), 17–29. doi:10.6106/jcepm.2012.2.3.017.
[47] Abeysinghe, N., & Jayathilaka, R. (2022). Factors influencing the timely completion of construction projects in Sri Lanka. PLoS ONE, 17(12 December), 278318. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0278318.
[48] CCEO (2002), Report on Caricom Construction and Installation Services Sector Elements for Competitive Strategies. Council of Caribbean Engineering Organisations, Jamaica.
[49] D. Adamu, A. A. S. (2013). Appraisal of Building Defects Due To Poor Workmanship in Public Building Projects in Minna, Nigeria. IOSR Journal of Engineering, 3(9), 30–38. doi:10.9790/3021-03933038.
[50] Abdul-Rahman, H., Wang, C., Wood, L. C., & Khoo, Y. M. (2014). Defects in Affordable Housing Projects in Klang Valley, Malaysia. Journal of Performance of Constructed Facilities, 28(2), 272–285. doi:10.1061/(asce)cf.1943-5509.0000413.
[51] Zunguzane, N., Smallwood, J., & Emuze, F. (2012). Perceptions of the quality of low-income houses in South Africa: Defects and their causes. Acta Structilia, 19(1), 19–38.
[52] Othuman Mydin, M. A., Agus Salim, N. A., Tan, S. W., Tawil, N. M., & Ulang, N. M. (2014). Assessment of Significant Causes to School Building Defects. E3S Web of Conferences, 3. doi:10.1051/e3sconf/20140301002.
[53] Soleimanzadeh, S., & Othuman Mydin, M. A. (2013). Influence of high temperatures on flexural strength of foamed concrete containing fly ash and polypropylene fiber. International Journal of Engineering, Transactions B: Applications, 26(2), 117–126. doi:10.5829/idosi.ije.2013.26.02b.02.
[54] Al-Sedairy, S. T. (2001). A change management model for Saudi construction industry. International Journal of Project Management, 19(3), 161–169. doi:10.1016/S0263-7863(99)00067-8.
- This work (including HTML and PDF Files) is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
